Each Achatz pie is handmade and baked fresh to order. It is quick frozen so that it stays fresh and delicious. There are fourteen flavors of dessert pies to choose from. Each is $39.95.
Betty’s Pies offers eighteen varieties and they all sound delicious. Toffee Cream, Butterfinger, and Apple Crunch to name a few flavors. The pies are shipped via Fed Ex and are $24.95 each.
The Little Pie Company in Manhattan makes eight different pies. The Key Lime and Mississippi Mud pies look wonderful. The pies are 10”, are $65 each and shipping (2-day air) is included.
Tootie Pie Company in Texas makes thirteen different pies. Prices range from $30 – $35 per pie. Flavors include Cherry, Lemon Velvet, Buttermilk and Coconut Supreme.
Cutie Pies NYC makes their pies by hand using fresh, organic and locally sourced ingredients. They sell artisanal scones, petite personal pies and their five large 9” pies – pumpkin, apple, bourbon pecan, pear-cranberry and lemon cream. The 9” pies are $30.00 each.
If you are in the market for savory pies, try Hancock Gourmet lobster pot pies. They are delicious! A four-pack of single serving pot pies is $69.95 and they are worth every penny.
Two tips on buying pies online:
Look at the ingredients used in the pies
Don’t order peach or berry pies – they can be too wet
Turn ordering pies into an equipment shopping opportunity:
This serrated pie server is a multi-tasker because it slices and serves. It is serrated on both sides. $8.95.
This French ceramic pie dish is large enough to put your ordered pie right into! It can also be used to bake deep dish pies should you ever have enough time to make a pie from scratch. It comes in five colors. $44.00.
This is a dressier pie server with a vintage look. $29.00.
Put on this Le Creuset snappy pot holder when you serve your pie and your guests may think you baked it. $11.95.